Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Teacher Caught on Tape Bullying Student. Is a Camera a Kid's Only Advocate?

    Nobody believed Julio Artuz, a 15 year old New Jersey special education student, when he complained of being bullied by his teacher. So he caught the whole thing on tape. In footage captured in secret on his cellphone, Artuz is subjected to curses and berating from a man who's supposed to be a mentor.

    Artuz's teacher says: "I will kick your [expletive] from here to kingdom come until I'm 80 years old."


    "Don't threaten me," responds Artuz.

    "What are you going to do? You gonna get a chopper and chop me?" asks his teacher as the rest of the class sits rubbernecking the heated argument.

    What Jules did do was show his taped account to his parents and a local advocate of bullied students. After an NBC news affiliate in Philadelphia got hold of the footage (you can watch it here), the school immediately took action, placing the teacher on paid administrative leave pending an investigation.



     

    "The actions depicted on the video do not reflect the mission or culture of our school," said Gloucester Counter Special Services Superintendent Michael Dicken in a statement. "Our school district takes all bullying, harassment, and intimidation allegations seriously...we do not tolerate it."

    While schools may not tolerate that kind of abuse of power, it takes a lot to make it stop. In a separate incident earlier this week, an Ohio special needs student came forward with an account of long-term bullying from her two teachers. She actually had to attend school wired with a recording device to capture proof of her teachers calling her "dumb", "lazy" and overweight. Another shocking incident this month involved a high school basketball coach who was captured on cell phone video making deeply offensive, racist remarks about students while in school.

    "Statistically about 1 to 2 percent of teachers are actually involved in bullying students," says Dr. Joel Haber, a clinical psychologist who runs the anti-bullying website RespectU. "There needs to be a clear policy in schools not just for students bullying other students but for teachers as well. Teachers are humans too and this kind of thing does happen, so it needs to be managed early."

    While more schools have introduced anti-bullying codes of conduct for students, teachers aren't always considered a threat.

    It's a murky issue for many school administrators. Where's the bullying line when you're managing an unruly classroom? "Its blurry sure but you know when someone wants to make a kid feel bad, or when  they're abusing their power as an authority figure," says Dr. Haber. "That's not the way a role model should be managing a student. "

    A bullying teacher doesn't just threaten to knock a student's self-confidence, he can destroy a kid's confidence in his school. "Teachers are supposed to make students feel safe," Dr. Haber says. When school becomes a fearful environment because of a teacher, students suddenly think 'well who can I trust then?'"

    In Artuz' case, his phone was best bet. It's possible nobody would have listened if they didn't see it firsthand. "When you watch a video like that live, it really creates a different image than if you were to just hear about," says Dr. Haber.

    It's a powerful defense, especially for students who don't feel their complaints would be recognized otherwise. It also sends a message to teachers: watch how you speak to your students, someone might be taping you.



    More from Shine on Yahoo! Canada

    Signs your child is being bullied

    School bus bullying

    The battle against bullying

     
     
    Top Locations Mississauga Yarmouth

    296 comments

    • Brian  •  Mississauga, Ontario  •  2 months ago
      Before any of you jump in and start defending teachers with your lamentations of how ill-behaved some students are today, you should stop and consider the fact that authority figures must always be held to a higher standard of behaviour than their subordinates. Failing to meet such a standard proves one unworthy of holding a position of authority, which entails increased responsibility granted in the hope that it will be used for the benefit of those over which one has authority.

      There are protocols in place for managing recalcitrant students. Send them to the principal's office. Call their parents. If all else fails, call the police (although, if you get to this step, chances are that you're simply an incompetent disciplinarian). But there is simply no justification for a teacher engaging in any kind of behaviour that resembles bullying a student.
    • Miss Peach  •  6 months ago
      People should always treat people as if they are wearing a recording device. The world would be a better place.
    • p  •  6 months ago
      The kid coud've called him every name in the book, if you react you get fired! SIMPLE
    • Maureen  •  6 months ago
      Paid leave? You mean paid vacation. Fire his #$%$ and see to it he can never teach again. Kids have enough peer pressure, they don't need this added to it.
    • trailmix_21  •  6 months ago
      I had a teacher bully me in high school. They completed my class transfer and when I looked in my file when I was left alone in the office the teacher had written "Do not like student's personality".
      So the teacher was picking on me from day 1 because he decided he just didnt like me. Strange because I was extremely quiet in class. So it was based on looks and assumptions.
    • Gregory  •  6 months ago
      A teacher cannot yell at a student like this without other teachers or administrators overhearing him. I'm sorry. Any excuse made by his colleagues are lies. They knew about it. They should all be held accountable.
    • Sneaks  •  6 months ago
      The school immediately took action by placing him on paid leave?Well done, give the guy a paid holiday.fire his #$%$ what investigation process? The teacher is on tape, that's your proof.
    • no better than u  •  6 months ago
      unions protect this type of idiot, not school boards! i wish i had a recording device when i was young, my word was all i had and it didn't get me anywhere with the powers above hurray for kids like this
    • I Speak the Truth  •  6 months ago
      It's always fun to beat up on teachers in the public forum, isn't it? This guy is an a$$hat for what he did and deserves to lose his job, but I'll tell you this: there are plenty of teachers that get bullied by older students and/or their parents, or administrators, and no one bats an eyelash. Students these days have so many rights, no one remebers that they have plenty of responsibilities, too. Responsibilities such as not being disrespectful to teachers. The vast majority of teachers do a great job, but have to put up with all kinds of crap from impudent, lippy trash-talking brats. Don't put a hate-on for all teachers just because of a few jerks like this guy.
    • brille  •  6 months ago
      Ha! One to two percent of teachers are involved in bullying students......really! I bet it's more like 10 percent and that may even be a low number. Bullying comes in all forms, not just verbal.
      • Brunhilda Swecker 6 months ago
        ..I rather doubt teachers physically bully students that often. It would get pretty obvious.
        What other kinds of bullying are you referring to? Glaring? Not smiling? Not waving? Not constantly praising mediocrity?
      • JohnJeep23 6 months ago
        No kidding, if there was all these kinds of bullying that teachers do I think that percentile would be more around the 90-95 percent range. There is a fine line between constructive and abusive discipline but know one these days knows how.
      • I Speak the Truth 6 months ago
        10%? Do you have scientific data to back that up or are you just shooting off your obviously biased mouth?
    • KittyCat  •  6 months ago
      PS ... And, if a teacher were to videotape a child's misbehaviour, they would be fired.
    • dea  •  6 months ago
      One other thing I'd like to mention is that this incident SHOULD go on the teacher's record!!!
    • Cory  •  6 months ago
      what an asshole!
      • mrknowitallme 6 months ago
        agreed, that little A-hole with a camera needs a good swat on the bum.
    • Jenny  •  5 months ago
      My brother is special needs and he was constantly bullied by several different teachers throughout his 13 years of going to school. I am glad that at least in this day and age there is technology that can capture the proof because really who is going to believe the student over the teacher. I hope they fire this teacher. He shouldn't be teaching.
    • Candice  •  6 months ago
      There's no excuse for any of this at all. They are there to teach, not offer opinions on a student's weight, looks, or make racist comments or threaten them. Fire his #$%$ don't give him a paid vacation. What more do you need? It's on tape!
      • A Yahoo! User 6 months ago
        well, they are there to teach, but most of the time they are there to manage the classroom ie. babysit. Teaching often gets interrupted by student's bad behaviour. Just saying that the statement, "they are there to teach" isn't seeing the whole picture.
      • Brunhilda Swecker 6 months ago
        we also don't know the whole story. I mean, who just starts yelling at a kid like that? Someone who's been provoked, and provoked over a long time-period, that's who.
    • Indian_by_Birth  •  6 months ago
      In the good old days ... teachers were respected and revered and in turn teachers considered the students as their own sons or daughters. But for a few, most teachers are nice and friendly and most students want to show that they can not be tamed. Once they grow up they realize how stupid they were. I was like that too, but I never gave up my education. Still learning so many things at 35.
    • Shirin  •  6 months ago
      I hope they fire this asshole, he's just left a horrible memory in this child's mind and will last forever, some teachers are real sob's and should be screened every year!!!
    • ghost  •  6 months ago
      is this stupid story still going on what about the teachers that are bullied and called names in front of the entire class and in some cases a student brings a weapon to school and threatened and dont tell me it does not happen it does as for the kids parents they to are most likely just as bad but at 15 the kid should have developed some kind of brain.and no the difference between right and wrong these particular kid should have the shit beat out of them they can be just as dangerous to a teacher as an adult can be look up history hitlers nazi youth group carrying guns and killing people SO these STUDENT in school bullying teachers and threatening them on line and at school are no better they stage and set these senarios up just to get attention most of the people in this forum that say poor little boy you sound like do gooders or people that have run into problems in the past with childerens aid and have been taught that kids can do no wrong well to you people GROW SOME BALLS this kid staged it just to raise shit let see how it plays out iam with the teachers look at the shit they have to put up with and the parents know cause these kid are just as bad at home and the parents only send them to school so they can get a break from the kids shitGROW UP YOU DO GOODERS
    • Savannah  •  6 months ago
      Its all back and forth. Teacher Vs. Student. So I say install "Security camera's in the class rooms this way everyone is held accountable. Teachers and students. If a parent claims "OH not my child" then show them security video's proving otherwise. Schools are becoming prisons now anyway with security guards, Metal detectors, uniforms so why not camera's. This way no-one can say 1 person is right the other wrong. this way protects eveyone. and removes any doubt. This case the video says it all. Teachers are suppose to nurture, this one belittled and beat down. So replace him.
    • joe  •  6 months ago
      Everyone is complaining about the paid leave situation. I would think they have to do that for legal reasons(union) before an investigation takes place. It may be a vacation for now, but he is facing the inevitable firing that will occur once this story goes viral,, which it already has,,,,,,. Not sure what the union strength is, in these parts, but,, they would surely back away, eventually,, from this bad publicity.
      Not saying that some disciplinary action is not needed,, but even with the vid ,, an investigation is still necessary to determine all facts. So often,, the guilty guilty mob mentality sets in. Do you know how easy to destroy a career such as a teacher can be? A few disgruntled kids and/or parents with some well timed words and bamm,, career over. And there's not a lot someone can do about it. Even his colleagues will run for the hills not wanting anything to do with this guy,, regardless if it be true or false .
      If it's discovered and proven that this is an ongoing problem with this particular teacher then yes a decision for discipline would be needed. Should it be an all out firing? Thats for someone else to decide, but there will surely be lawyers on both sides involved if it came to that.
      I'm sure they will keep us all posted and up to date regardless.
    POLL
    Loading...
    Poll Choice Options