Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Rachel McAdams vs. Nicole Kidman — Fashion Faceoff

    Welcome to an international edition of Fashion Faceoff! Both Canadian actress Rachel McAdams ("The Notebook") and Australian-born leading lady Nicole Kidman ("The Hours") tried out the lace trend in the "Mirabella" dress by Collette Dinnigan within just three days of each other. Now it's up to us to decide ... who wore it better?

    Hannes Magerstaedt/Getty Images, Frazer Harrison/Getty Images
     

     achel, 33, rocked the design to promote her new tearjerker, "The Vow," in Munich, Germany, on January 30. She added black pumps and left her now-blond locks in curls cascading over her shoulders.

    Nicole, 44, chose the look for her appearance at the 2012 Australian Academy of Cinema and Television Arts Awards in West Hollywood, California, on January 27. The "Moulin Rouge" star accessorized with strappy silver sandals and left her strawberry-blond strands down.

    OK, it's time to call this style battle, which is tough since both ladies are working the look. Nicole's coloring against the dress is absolutely gorgeous, but Rachel's frock fits better, making her look more polished overall. I think, then, it comes down to the choice of shoes, and the answer there is clear: Rachel's black footwear makes her look frumpy from the hemline down, while Nicole's skimpy shoes ensure the view of her long and lean silhouette is uninterrupted. For me, Nicole is the winner. Do you agree?

    Related stories:

    The dress that weighs 100 pounds

    Kim Kardashian vs. Nicole Kidman in fashion faceoff

    Beyonce accused of skin lightening

     

    65 comments

    • A Yahoo! User  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      the one who does ATM wins
      • Meds 3 months ago
        Ankle To Middle-finger?
    • montreal gal  •  Montreal, Quebec  •  3 months ago
      I think both women are beautiful but this dress does not suit either of them. The colour nor style does nothing for them
    • Um Believable  •  3 months ago
      Funny how it looks like a different dress on each of them.
    • Sadna.R  •  Newmarket, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      i just say both dress look good on them
    • Lonetta H. Pinky  •  3 months ago
      Doesn`t matter to me, both of them get my vote, therefore it`s a tie between the two actresses. Obviously, the accessories and shoes make the dress look a little different. Depends what everyone on Yahoo thinks. To me, they both rock that dress with style!
    • christinator...  •  Moncton, New Brunswick  •  3 months ago
      They both look great, but it looks a size too small on the top for Nicole
    • concerned  •  3 months ago
      Rachel wins....her dress fits. Nicole .....dress looks much to short in the body on her as the strap should sit on her should but won't even reach up there.

      I would notice the dress first. If it looks terrible I wouldn't even paid any attention to her shoes or other accessories.

      It is the same fabric but of course just cut from different parts of the cloth which is what makes bodice and waist line appear a little different.
    • Middleman11  •  London, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Not trying to be mean but that dress accentuates how low Nicole's bosom is.
      • Helga Pataki 3 months ago
        Totally agree, and Nicole's poor posture doesn't help any. But rachel definitely is in the winning seat.
    • Lost in Translation  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Rachel wins -- hands down! Let's not mention her face is real, unlike that plastic mask the other one is wearing!
    • chelsea...  •  Swift Current, Saskatchewan  •  3 months ago
      macadams !
    • Eternal  •  3 months ago
      Rachel!!!!!!!!!!!!
    • My 2 Cents...  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Rachel wins hands down! But hey she's my neighbour and she looks awesome every day!
    • elisabeth  •  Toronto, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      disagree, Rachel is the winner
    • Tily  •  3 months ago
      Dam that Canadian girl looks great , too bad the Aussie looks like she is about to take it off!
    • julian  •  Puebla, Mexico  •  3 months ago
      If you call the dress identical is like saying that you have seen 2 identical zebras. The dresses have different pattern for those who pay attention to details. Check carefully and you'll see.
    • SharonR  •  Edmonton, Alberta  •  3 months ago
      I like it better on Rachel. It fits better and doesn't bunch around the hips and waist. I don't know what the writer's problem is with Rachel's shoes - they're just plain black pumps.
    • hoodlum  •  3 months ago
      Rachel wins and doesn't look frumpy at all. Nicole looks like she stuffed herself into a size or 2 smaller than she should be wearing.
    • Jason  •  Georgina, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Not one hundred perscnt identical. Pattern is just slightly different. Definately a good look for both of them.
      • Jason 3 months ago
        Sorry for the spelling error. Should have been percent. Yes: I'm anal. Especially where I'm concerned. But then, who better to judge.
    • outspoken  •  3 months ago
      Does the reporter not know the definition of identical? These dresses are very similar, they are not identical.
    • devilgal_91  •  St Catharines, Ontario  •  3 months ago
      Rachel without a doubt. Not only sticking up to my fellow Canadian girl but she looks so gorgeous and happy! Nicole although it's a nice dress, it's too low on her chest and unless she's got the ta-tas which she doesn't, sorry..my vote goes to Rachel
    POLL
    Loading...
    Poll Choice Options