Discover Yahoo! With Your Friends

Explore news, videos, and much more based on what your friends are reading and watching. Publish your own activity and retain full control.

To get started, first

YOUR FRIENDS' ACTIVITY

    Guess which province is the hardest place in Canada to raise a young family

    Guess which province is the hardest place in Canada to raise a  young family


    Payday, at least in my household, dovetails nicely with "chequing account overdraft evening" and "next-day desperate scratch ticket purchase." As quickly as I receive compensation for my efforts (direct deposit rules), it's gone: marched off grimly to pay down my credit cards, student loans, utilities, sizeable grocery bills (a girl's gotta eat her feelings after all) and rent. I'm sure I'm forgetting something, but the good thing is creditors are always ready to remind me. 

    The cardio-heavy payday shuffle is the norm for millions of Canadians who struggle to stay on top of their bills and expenses, but for young families the physical and emotional strain may be even greater. And according to a recent report nowhere in the nation is that more true than in the province of British Columbia. 

    An article in the Vancouver Sun cites a recent report by a researcher at the University of British Columbia that found that couples with young children in B.C. have seen their standard of living significantly decrease in comparison to young families who reside in the rest of the country. 

    In fact, B.C. is the only province in Canada that has seen such a decline in the household income of this age group in the past three decades. 

    Paul Kershaw of UBC's Human Early Learning Partnerships found that household incomes for couples between the ages of 25 to 34 have dropped by six percent since the late 1970s. 

    And this state of affairs isn't because people are working less. As the article notes, women have increased their financial contribution to the household by more than 40 percent since the late 70s. 

    If they're working harder than before, what's keeping young couples on the financial ropes in B.C.? An over-the-top housing market may not be helping matters. Vancouver Sun writer Tara Carman points out that B.C. real estate prices have risen 149 percent since 1976. 

    Back then, she writes, "housing costs accounted for less than three times the average household income for young couples. Today, it is seven times as much."

    More stories from Chatelaine

    Connect with Chatelaine:

     

    275 comments

    • galex  •  6 months ago
      Sound like most of you are talking about Vancouver not British Columbia as a whole. Move up North- no shortage of work and more than resonable housing market. Yes the groceries, and shopping is more expensive but the wages are also much higher. Minimum wage is only heard of if you are straight out of school. Even 7-11 starts off at 14 or 15 an hour with full benefit pkg. Work in one of the coal mines starting at 30+ an hour. Get into the Oil and Gas and you are not likely to work under 50 an hour, plus full benefits - so I say Bullshit to this one!!
    • Boomer  •  7 months ago
      Born & raised in BC. The prices in the lower mainland (Vancouver area) are out of sight. You can still get some nice houses & condos in other parts of the province for "normal" prices, but the jobs aren't always there though. What's killing us is the Provincial government we have had in place for the past 11 years. They play to friends and insiders and couldn't give a rat's backside for the average working person. Sad because it really is a beautiful (but expensive) place to live.
      • IW 7 months ago
        It probably has something to do with the attitude of newer generations too though. I don't think you'd get our parents' generation blaming their woes on the government, and they had to contend with worse politicians.
    • dandksmom  •  7 months ago
      BC is a beautiful province, and I miss my family who lives there. But this article is the biggest reason why we live elsewhere.
      • 7 months ago
        How long can you stare at a mountain?
      • Pablo Escobar 7 months ago
        CF - Don't knock it till you tried it :)
      • Bluenoser 7 months ago
        I can stare at a mountain a long time. Use to live in between two mountains in Arizona and what a treat. The colors of the sunrise on one mountain in the morning was awesome and a great way to start the day. Sit on the porch and watch that and then the colors on the other mountain at sunset, what a way to end the day. Yup, if it wasn't for the heat I would still be there, but so glad to be home. Now I can stare at the ocean.
    • I, person  •  7 months ago
      This will surprise no one who lives in BC except the ones in the Ivory Towers (politicians).
    • *  •  7 months ago
      Having lived and raised families for a good number of years in a good number of places in Europe and North America, I must agree, that BC is the most expensive place I've ever lived in. I don't see, how people here even make it without 2 household incomes, unless they belong to the wealthy doctor/lawyer/corporate class. And things aren't getting better here, but rather worse. Let's keep raising municipal taxes, increase water rates, up the utilities, raise sub-standard rents and grocery prices, while wages stay somewhere in 'low down' land. No, honestly, BC is the pitts to live in, and I wish I didn't have to live here with my family and could afford moving to a place, where one can have a life other than perpetual, 7 days a week, work with nothing to show for but struggle and more bills.
      • bob 7 months ago
        psstt....the wealthy/corporate class is not a secret club. You too can be wealthier if you choose. But you might have to sacrifice severely for a decade or two and take risks. I know so many people who claim they struggle that spend a fair bit of time sitting on the sofa watching tv each week and a bunch of people who are very comfortable financially who opt not to take that road.
      • T 7 months ago
        3 words. Native American's checks
    • Sector 7G  •  7 months ago
      Just my two cents worth but I am in my mid forties and when my parents first moved here almost 46 years ago they bought a nice corner lot home in Burnaby for what they thought was a high price of $14,750.00 ! That same home today (yes, it's still there) just sold for $879,000.00 !!! Almost 60 times the price! I can tell you this for a fact, I am not making 60 times the salary that my father was earning in the 60's! And I am not going to put the blame on any group of people as home market gouging seems to trancend all groups. It would be up to our government to start to devalue homes to an affordable level for the average income worker but that is unlikely as there are too many groups such as bankers, tax collectors and real estate brokers who benefit from rediculously high prices. IMHO.
      • lina22346 7 months ago
        Balloon popping in 3,2,1...
    • Tim  •  7 months ago
      If the statisticians in Canada would survey who lives pay to pay in this country, they would be shocked. It affects all peoples not just the young and young families and in all provinces.
      Many after they graduate university can only find part time work with benefits. Older people on fixed incomes really struggle not to meantion those in there 40's and 50's who have been caught up in restructuring and downsizing only to find employment at marginal paying jobs.
      And the liberal government here in Ontario plans on subsidizing employers who hire recent immigrants when in fact recent graduates, born in this country, cannot even find full time employment.. Many people are now facing retirement years with no savings whatsoever. Many banked on CPP which pays next to nothing after the government used our monies since the mid sixties.

      It is a sham and our goverments, federal and provincial are totally out of touch with reality and the average citizen. That is why the protests going on across the world are vital.
      Citizens need to take hold of their governments. Down with the favouratism and political contributions by the rich and big business. Big business should not be allowed to lobby nor should they be allowed to contribute to political campaigns. Lobbyists should not be permitted at any level of government.

      There is such a thing as white collar theft. They need to think twice cause "hell" is a "hell of a long time" when the least amongst us are being shafted right left and centre.
      • ehs moh 7 months ago
        I agree Tim
      • MAREK 7 months ago
        !!!!!!!!
      • Don 7 months ago
        I would be interested in seeing a list of the degrees people who graduate with and still can't find employement. If we need doctors and nuses, why take sociology. If there is a need for marine biologists why study ancient history and dead languages. We are a country with a declining birth rate, how many teachers do we need to graduate when school populations are in overall decline......oh wait, we will need ESL teachers to help out the doctors and engineers who immigrate to the country from Asia.
    • a yahoo user  •  7 months ago
      Wow, earth shattering news again on Yahoo. I do not live in BC, but have visited twice in the last year for significant amounts of time. If your family is not bringing in well over $100,000 K per year, very tough to make a go. Real estate values are ridiculous, gas prices are among the highest in the country, and there are numerous eco taxes to boot. Beautiful province though if you like driving up and down and around - lol. Needless to say, I am a flatlander and loving it.
    • vnavic  •  7 months ago
      BC also has the lowest minimum wage in the entire country, go figure. The government will is to raise it to a whole 10.25 in May of next year, wow. Hell, try living off of 18.00 an hour here, can't be done. I guess I could always move to Fort McMurray, but it's Fort McMurray, yuck!!!!
    • real solution  •  7 months ago
      If you are a regular working person living on the island, you get to be punished even more. How much does it cost now to cross over to the mainland? Over $100 return easy. And what about death taxes and the funeral costs? I can't afford to die in B.C., let alone live there.
    • greg  •  7 months ago
      My 27 yr old daughter lives in Vancouver and tells me she never wants to return to small town Ontario where she grew up. I can understand that, but have to wonder how she ever expects to afford a house there.
    • Eselle  •  7 months ago
      I live in BC and I agree with article. Everything just seems to be getting more costly.
    • Bob  •  6 months ago
      Want to control costs? Do what the Indians and Chinese do, have 3-4 families living in one average sized bungallo, sharing rent/mortage. That's the future of Van and surrounding areas, one big slum like Mumbai.
    • Anonymous  •  7 months ago
      pretty much everyone in vancouver is struggling; even homeowners are up to their necks in mortgages 500 - 700K loans; work, work, work just to keep up
    • Standford Von Bight-Me  •  7 months ago
      Metro Vancouver is a great place to live, providing you got in two or more decades ago. It is almost impossible for a young person, single or married, to start out on their own and live half way comfortably. Many still have to rely on mom and dad. That's why I question the mentality of people that when BC Place employees, postal workers, Air Canada flight attendants and others fight to retain what security they have and get a small pay increase, the chattering class yells "crucify them, crucify them". Even worse, our minimum wage had been set 10 years ago, it is the lowest in Canada, and the chattering class still come out and oppose increasing it.
    • slippy  •  7 months ago
      wow go figure

      we have a tax happy government that bends over to corporate interests while handing out piles of cash in subsidies and tax cuts leaving the little guy to make up the difference only to have our cost of living raised plus we send way to much of our tax dollars back to Ottawa
    • Jody  •  7 months ago
      spare some change anybody?
    • electropersona  •  7 months ago
      GoCanucks and Quark said it perfectly. Too many people NOT living in Canada nor have they contributed to the system, have been buying out properties, which not only robs our own citizens of property ownership, but this is also the cause of the housing prices being so unrealistic and not matching the worth and income levels of citizens. There must be a law that makes it a requirement for people buying properties to be living in Canada or have done so extensively in the past but return as well. And yes, there is still slavery going around but in a quiet way. Canada is like a fake country and is still very much a colony. No wonder most immigrants these days to Canada are from the commonwealth countries. Sadly from lower commonwealth countries.
    • Scotoma  •  7 months ago
      I was born here in Vancouver and have lived for short periods years ago in Toronto, Lethbridge AB, and Winnipeg. in BC Vancouver Isld and Chilliwack. I believe it is the foreign purchase of pricey homes in Vancouver (mostly on the west side) that has helped raise the prices. However I never expect to be able to afford a home of my own or even a condo.
    • Allen  •  6 months ago
      I lived in Victoria for a few years. The mountains were nice, the ocean as well but you can only look at them for so long. The reality was, Victoria was old money. They called it white Victoria with mostly Irish, Scotish and British people pretty well owning the city. If you weren't from there, they didn't want to do business with you. I remember most young couples having a desperate time getting by there.
    POLL
    Loading...
    Poll Choice Options